Volume 124: 02/01/06

Didn't You Say This was on Sale?

Sometimes you go to a website and you just know the business hasn't got a clue. They're doing everything so wrong, you don't even know where to start. There are also those times you go to a site and think, on first inspection, that things look pretty good.

Until you start dealing with the site's process. In that moment you realize appearances can be deceiving. That's why, through the use of personas and wireframed scenarios, we always make sure our clients are getting their processes squeaky clean first.  It's basic Horse Before the Cart 101.

Our friend and colleague David Cross was trying to buy a long sleeved t-shirt from a company called C&C California. Here's what happened.

From the home page, David selected the women's category ...

... then clicked on the "Long Sleeve Tees" subcategory from a drop-down menu. That landed him here:

Excellent! Lots of long sleeve tees with an attractive one on sale for 35 percent off! David clicked on it:

Hmmm. No indication of the sale price. In fact, not a mention of any sort of sale. Maybe the sale price is reflected in the shopping cart. So David selected a brown color (attractively called "mudslide") from a drop-down menu offering 19 options, a size, then clicked "Add to Bag."

Full price. Not good. So David emailed C&C California. Customer Service replied, "Sorry for the confusion, but only certain colors are on sale. If you go to the 'Sale' tab located at the top of the page, it will bring up the colors that are on sale for $35.75."

Non-plussed, David replied, "That's not clear from your website - it states "Extra Long Sleeve Tee SAVE 35% $55.00 now $35.75. Two other products at that page suffer the "Well, we know it's only certain colors so the customer should, too!" syndrome. Have your online marketers check your web analytics for people who bail when getting to the product page." Then David bailed and sent us the story.

How could I let this go? I slipped into my trench coat, grabbed my magnifying glass, then cruised over to C&C. First time through the site, I followed David's path and got David's disappointing results: the tee on sale that isn't necessarily a tee on sale.  But I knew about getting at these babies through the "Sale" link, so I clicked on the sale link in the top nav ...

... and landed on a subcategory page where everything listed was on sale:

I easily found the long sleeve tee David was hoping to buy in the upper right and clicked on it:

The product page I landed on looked exactly like the product page David landed on, except this time, the page reflected the product's sale status. I selected a color choice (12 of the 19 colors were on sale, and the color featured on the page wasn't one of them), a size, then added it to my bag. It worked.

Two long sleeve tee links that look exactly the same, but take you to different places, only one of which fulfills the promise of a sale.  With the first bad experience under your belt, you'd have to really want this tee from this business to bother sticking with it.

It gets worse!

I started wondering:  if a visitor followed the obvious scenario path through the site - as David did - that visitor wouldn't know which colors were on sale. It would be hit or miss. So what happened if the visitor got lucky and inadvertently managed to choose a sale color without following the sale link?

Petunia was a sale color. So I went back to the sale-less product page and selected Petunia and a size. Then I clicked "Add to Bag." The product page refreshed, and this appeared just below the "Add to Bag" button:

Dang, but you've got to work hard for that 35 percent off!  I followed the "click here" link and landed on:

Yep. The sale version of the product page. And - you guessed it - I had to repeat the tasks of selecting my color, selecting my size and adding the item to my bag all over again! Yeah, right.

This is just about the most frustrating, counter-intuitive process I've come across in ages. Nice looking site, but C&C appears to have let some developer have far too much say in how the business should manage the online buying and selling process.

I figure the last thing C&C wants to do is sell these sale items - they certainly don't make it easy. Count the clicks. Only the most motivated of individuals is going to stick with it (there are a few of them out there, but only a few). And that's assuming those individuals can even find the sale items!

But C&C's biggest mistake came early on, when they featured a sale item on a subcategory page with a link that took the visitor to a product page that didn't even mention the word "sale." Broken promises break relationships. They don't make for happy endings.

David's right. I'll bet the rejection rate on the sale-less product page is way up there. Bye-bye C&C.

The moral of this story? Having a site that's visually attractive isn't enough. You must set up your site processes so they reflect how your customers want to buy, not how you want to sell! Think like your customers. Don't ever make your customers have to figure out how to think like you. And never, ever break a promise by failing to deliver on a click!

Train to Increase Your Conversion Rates

New Services

We've been busy bees over the holidays.  Check out our services page - new services have already been launched and more are coming!

New Publications

You'll also want to keep an eye on our publications page.  We've been working on creating resources that will help you put many of our principles into practice more easily and more efficiently.  We're just about to release several of our newest products, including Which Sells Best?: A Quick Start Guide to Testing for Retailers and The Conversion Experts Handbook.

What Site Visitors Find Annoying

Ever since the dawn of time ... well, okay, March 15, 2000 ... I've been saying "Don't do it" when it comes to those irritating online practices that send your visitors scurrying for your competitors. I've told you they'll bail on you, and that bailing once is usually the same as bailing forever. You tick off a visitor, and they don't come back to let you do it again.

Thing is, a customer bails and it doesn't necessarily remain a private matter between you and the individual. That disgruntled customer is just as likely to start spreading the news through all those lovely consumer-generated media venues. You know ... blogs and reviews and lists.

So here we are, well and truly rooted in a media-rich market that has upended all the relationships we used to take for granted. These days, the customer is in control. And that customer is growing increasingly intolerant of shabby online experiences.

You simply can't shrug it off. So, with help from Hostway, here are some impressive numbers that should put teeth into the stuff I've been telling you ... ever since the dawn of time!

Hostway's national Pet Peeve survey assembled a list of 15 irritating website practices:1

  1. Pop-up ads

  2. Requiring the installation of extra software to view the site

  3. Dead links

  4. Requirement to register and log-on before viewing the website

  5. Slow-loading pages

  6. Content that is out of date

  7. Confusing navigation - hard-to-find pages, too many clicks

  8. Ineffective site search tool

  9. No contact information available (web form only)

  10. Inability to use the browser's back button

  11. Overdone sites - unnecessary splash/flash screens or animation

  12. Text that moves

  13. Music or other audio that plays automatically

  14. Poor appearance - colors, fonts, format

  15. Opening a new window for a link

Then Hostway asked their respondents how they felt about each of these. What did visitors find annoying? Well, it would be easier to tell you what the majority of folks didn't find annoying. Only (only?) 38 percent of the respondents found 'opening a new window for a link' irritating.

The biggest bugbear: Pop-up advertisements. Ninety-three percent!

Eighty-something percent found Peeves 2 through 8 very or extremely annoying. Seventy-something percent were ticked off by Peeves 9 and 10. 'Overdone sites' ticked off 69 percent of respondents. And aesthetic issues like moving text, automatic audio and poor appearances scored in the 50s.2

Pop-up ads were everybody's favorite pet peeve by a landslide. Requiring visitors to register or log on before viewing content and requiring visitors to download additional software to make the site word came in second and third, respectively.

Then Hostway asked folks what they'd do when they came face to face with their pet peeve (cue the ominous opening of Beethoven's Fifth):

  • 76% said they'd never come back to the site

  • 74% said they'd unsubscribe from promotions and mailings

  • 71% said they'd never purchase from the site

  • 71% said they'd view the company negatively

  • 54% said they'd complain to friends and associates

  • 45% said they wouldn't buy from the company's brick-and-mortar (if the company had one)

  • Only 24% said they'd take the time to complain directly to the company

These are some pretty devastating numbers. Never come back? Never do business with a different channel? Ouch!

The good news is, almost every single one of these peeves is easy to fix. Around here, we call this stuff the low-hanging fruit - deal with it, and you can give your conversion rates a nice booster shot.  You need to dig much deeper to achieve your potential, but these things make for a good start.

I'm certain none of my loyal readers are making these mistakes, but if you are, get that phone number into your site template. Put a real address on your Contact Us page.  Regularly review your content, including links, for freshness. Ditch the pop-up ads. Remove all the gimmicks. Work with developers to speed downloads and simplify your interface applications. Don't make folks have to register with you just to buy from you. And don't ever ask your customers to give up something they value (their contact information) without giving them a super good reason to do so.

If your customers won't put up with these shabby online experiences, why in the world would you?

1 "Survey says ... Internet pet peeves: what drives customers away from your e-business." Press Release. Hostway. August 1, 2005. http://www.hostway.com/aboutus/press_releases.html# Ratings were based on a five-point scale from 1 (not at all annoying) to 5 (extremely annoying). Percentages cited combine responses of 4 (very) and 5 (extremely).

2 You can find the exact results by visiting the above link, clicking on the press release, then following the results link at the end of the press release.

Volume 124: 02/01/06


Contact Us


Bi-Monthly Online Conversion Rate Marketing Newsletter:

We Value Your Privacy!

  • Cardscan
  • ProFlowers
  • GE
  • Leo Schachter Diamonds
  • Overstock.com
  • SAS
  • Disney
  • Gatelys.com
  • NBC Universal
  • PriceWaterhouseCoopers
  • Volvo International
  • Southern Company
  • BuyTelco
  • Allegis Group's Thingamajob
  • WebEx
  • CafePress
  • Elance